This controversy echoes previous debates about genre classification in the Grammy Awards, particularly regarding artists who blend multiple musical traditions. The decision recalls similar discussions surrounding other boundary-pushing artists and highlights the ongoing evolution of musical categorization in an increasingly globalized industry.

Last year, the young South African singer Tyla had a major global breakthrough with her hit “Water.” Earlier this year, that song won the first-ever Grammy for Best African Music Performance. One year later,

The unexpected category switch has left fans talking, especially considering the album’s blend of Amapiano, Afrobeats, and R&B influence — which aligns well with the Best Progressive R&B Album category.

The Recording Academy has reportedly moved South African singer Tyla’s eponymous debut album into the pop Grammys category despite the project being initially submitted in the R&B category. According to Hollywood Reporters,

Tyla won the first Grammy for best African music performance earlier this year, but her debut album will be in the pop category at the 2025 awards, according to an exclusive report The Hollywood Reporter.